Organic Church Today

Powered by Gottalife

I've become quite accustomed to the pro-required-tithing campers showing up in my camp at odd intervals throughout my life.

Being an avid forum participant all over the internet, I was asked why I don't tithe, knowing full well what's written in Malachi.

I answered the Malachi battering ram by pointing out that Malachi was addressing a people who were still under the lawful requirement to tithe, which is also true of the comments Jesus made. He too was addressing people who were still under the Law at the time.

I also countered with a question none of them were able to answer with legitimate exegesis. I asked, "Can you show me where the Law ever defined the tithe as being inclusive of a tenth of the wages from wage earners?"

Apart from the usual falsehoods perpetrated by the pro-required-tithing gangs, the silence only made my tinnitus more noticeable.

DM

Views: 206

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

What a joy we have in giving 100% of our lives knowing Jesus paid it all. It was Catholicism that introduce the tithe - one of the many points the first reformation did not deal with resulting in Protestant (protesting Catholic) religion adopting many false rituals. I have renounced protestant christianity and chose to follow Jesus Christ. the passage in Malachi was not addressing the people but the priests as the people could not rob from God as the tithe was presented on there behalf by the temple priests. you are right on there is not scripture that states a tithe should come from your wage slip because not all trades were required to pay the 10% tithe a blacksmith a carpenter and any trade outside of producing fruit from the land and livestock was not required to tithe. When Abraham gave to the great high priest the tithe he gave was not from him but from the plunder of a single battle. praise the Lord for his goodness and freedom we now have!!
I am a hilarious giver and will always be freely reaching out.

Amen to that.

 

It's also of interest that those who had, for example, only nine lambs or calves born in a year, they were not required to hand over anything.

 

One thing I will say is that I thoroughly appreciate the OT system of tithing because it met genuine needs. Today, many lavish the major, primary portion of their giving back upon themselves by way of various luxuries such as their communal facilities, staffing, programs, etc. That's not giving any more than handing dues over to the Elk, Moose, Beaver, Possum, Masonic, or whatever lodge in which one may be a member.

 

I'm so thankful to the Lord that He has given us the freedom to purpose in our hearts what to give, even though it's ALL His.

 

Again, Amen, brother.

 

Glory to the Most High.

I have seen a lot of sermons on the tithing, or giving; some of them very strange.  I remember some time a go when my adult daughter was a teen, and going through a very difficult time, was being hauled off in a police car. We called the pastor of the church we were attending, seeking some definite help as our world was falling apart. His response was, "Have you been tithing, like you should?" There are very few moments in my life when it seems as if the world was standing still....that was one of them. Anyhow, lots of sermons on tithing, but I have never heard or seen one sermon or a discussion about what was actually done with the old testament tithe, or even the New testament tithe for that matter.   

Michael,

I certainly understand what you're saying. Very few ministers ever speak the TRUTH about the tithe.

In OT times, the tithe was the inheritance of the Levites who were not allowed to make a living by any means as was common among the people of that day. The Levites also used a portion of the tithe to meet the needs of the fatherless, needy widows, and the strangers in the land.

Although there are some out there who seem to enjoy complicating the tithe, it really was a simple system that relied mostly upon personal honesty before God. Nobody came around to bird-dog those who owned producing lands, flocks and/or herd owners. It was an honor system.

Additionally, every third year, those who had what they were to tithe from, if they were too far from the appointed place to convey their tithe, they could sell it all, take the money to the appointed place, buy whatever their hearts "lusteth" after with the money, even strong drink, and partake of it all before the Lord, with all their household (including the servants), not forgetting the Levites.

Brother, that was a wonderful system that reflected the heart of God for the needy. It met needs AND allowed for thanksgiving celebrations before the Lord. No money touched the hands of the Levites from the people who handed over a tithe. No wage earners, like you and me, were required to hand over a portion of their wages, even though institutional church organizations teach otherwise.

From the perspective of the scriptures, tithing today is purely voluntary, not compulsory.

Unfortunately, many people rob God by handing over to organized religion their tithe, which for most people, is the largest, primary portion of what otherwise would have been their giving.

I say that because handing over what should be their giving to something from which they reap direct benefit isn't giving at all....not in accordance with biblical giving.

Never have I seen anyone give to the poor, and receive back any earthly benefit as they do from all the luxuries institutionalized religion affords those who support it.

That, my friend, is robbing God. When that which could have otherwise gone to help meet needs of fellow believers is used for luxurious slef-lavishment, we have robbed even the least of His.

I'm guilty of that very thing myself, but have been forgiven by the Lord.

Thank the Lord for having taken my sins upon Himself on that cross.

DM

Very interesting.  If you know of some book or material that dives a little deeper into the subject, I would appreciate it.  Send my a message if you know of anything.

I don't know of any books off the top of my head, but I know they're out there.

One place to start is the following link:

Tithing Article

And Another

Dr. Russel Earl Kelley had some interesting observations you might find of value:

Dr. Kelley's Website

I'll find some more resources to share with you as time allows.

DM

Thanks. Pretty good info.  Always felt like something was up.  Amazingly freeing, to have a man made burden lifted off of me.

Glad to have been of service to ya. Blessings to you and yours.

I tell you what amazes me the most: when you have theologians with PHD's preaching on people muts give a githe to God. I then remember that Christ will choose the foolish ( thats us) of the world. It is theivery when they steal from the members of the church. I would like to be nice but a thief is a thief.

I like reading both sides of the issue, and then reading for myself what is written in the Bible. Some thieves have PhD's, and some don't.

Darrell, I think you hit the nail on the head. Listen to both sides and then check what the bible actually says. People have this nasty habit of taking small texts out of context and using them to suit their own ends. When it involves tithing, it makes me want to sit down and make a whip...

RSS

Music

Loading…

Amazon Store Link

Badge

Loading…

Gottalife Links

Gottalife Radio Capture the Moment - with Rad Zdero


Business Development www.gottalife.net

Latest Activity

Jonathon Baer replied to Jo Lynne Deaver's discussion Don't Limit Opportunities
"To address your first paragraph: I, too, have been somewhat dismayed to see very little activity and interaction with this excellent medium. Kenny put a lot into this and it is a shame it isn't maximized. Second paragraph: Simply: Be ready,…"
13 hours ago
Profile IconLoretta Rodrigues and Maegan Verrett joined Organic Church Today
19 hours ago
Marvin Lorenzana shared their blog post on Twitter
yesterday
Marvin Lorenzana shared their blog post on Twitter
yesterday
Marvin Lorenzana shared their blog post on Twitter
yesterday
Jo Lynne Deaver posted a discussion

Don't Limit Opportunities

I want to start out by saying how thankful I am for OCT and the people who support and encourage so consistently. I am still learning my way around the site. I check the site every day for new stuff. I am surprised when I see that a lot of times I am the only one online.Wasn't really sure what to title this because I have a couple of things on my mind. Been really praying about what God wants me to do. Sometimes can get frustrated wanting to do something so big for God. But I have realized as I…See More
yesterday
Marvin Lorenzana posted a status
"Iglesia Alternativa? Parte V:Movimiento Multiplicador de Iglesias:¿Qué Es Un MMI? - I"
Saturday
Marvin Lorenzana shared their blog post on Twitter
Saturday
Marvin Lorenzana shared their blog post on Twitter
Saturday
Marvin Lorenzana shared their blog post on Twitter
Saturday
Mark McCune left a comment for Jo Lynne Deaver
"Thanks, i intend on updating my profile some more and getting to know some of the people and resources here!   Mark"
Friday
Jo Lynne Deaver left a comment for Pam Potoczek
"Welcome to OCT Pam, Look forward to your comments and hope you enjoy the site. In Christ, Jo Lynne  "
Friday
Jo Lynne Deaver left a comment for Mark McCune
"Welcome Mark, OCT is a great place for support and there are great resources. In Christ, Jo Lynne"
Friday
Jo Lynne Deaver left a comment for Rick Swenson
"Welcome Rick, Hope you enjoy OCT and get involved with the discussions. In Christ, Jo Lynne"
Friday
Jo Lynne Deaver left a comment for JoeJennifer Filer
"Welcome to Joe, Jennifer & family, Encouraging you on your journey and rethinking of Church. You will find lots of good resources here! In Christ, Jo Lynne  "
Friday
Marvin Lorenzana updated their profile
Friday
John Tyler posted a blog post
Thursday
Pablo Giacopelli posted a blog post

Leaving it behind

Hello Brothers and Sisters,This week I come to you from the top of the Arbel mountain where Jesus prayed after feeding the 5000. On my way down I stumbled with the view of a small town which is the place someone well known came from. Someone whom discovered in her journey something many of us know in our minds but not necessarily in our hearts.I hope it adds to your ammunition pack for the journey ahead of you!Travel WellPablo…See More
Thursday
Jo Lynne Deaver posted a status
"Ph'p:1:6: Being confident of this very thing, that he which hath begun a good work in you will perform it until the day of Jesus Christ:"
Thursday
Marvin Lorenzana shared their blog post on Twitter
Wednesday

© 2012   Created by Gottalife.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service